Planning Permit Application No. PP26/1282
Objection to the six-storey development at 38 Havelock Road, Hawthorn East

The proposal is to construct a six-storey apartment building and associated access into the narrow easement road at the rear of the property and then into Campbell Grove, Hawthorn East.
This proposal represents an extreme overdevelopment that threatens the liveability, safety, and infrastructure of our established neighbourhood. It creates a precedent for similar developments.
Granting permanent approval to a project of this scale under blanket interim rules risks inflicting irreversible damage on the community before a new mandate can review these sweeping changes.
The proposal suffers from several critical flaws that demand rigorous, independent scrutiny rather than a rushed assessment.
Key issues
- Neighbourhood scale and heritage interface: Transitioning directly from single- and double-storey homes straight to a six-storey mass ignores basic urban planning principles. The site sits immediately adjacent to mapped Heritage Overlays (HO852 and HO856), meaning the visual impact and loss of neighbourhood character must be properly evaluated.
- Severe infrastructure and drainage vulnerabilities: The site sits near a local laneway stormwater drain (near Campbell Grove) that already struggles with pooling, debris, and runoff from neighbouring basement pumps. A multi-level basement excavation and stormwater pump system risks overwhelming local infrastructure and causing severe localised flooding.
- Traffic safety and local congestion: Havelock Road and Campbell Grove are narrow, low-capacity local streets unequipped for heavy construction vehicles or the permanent influx of vehicle movements from a major apartment block. Traffic funnelling into intersections like Tooronga Road will compromise pedestrian safety and resident access. Adding dozens of daily vehicle movements puts pedestrians and school children at risk.
- Tree canopy and environmental protection: Under state tree canopy preservation regulations, surrounding vegetation requires rigorous independent impact assessment, regardless of individual council listings.
- Sunlight and privacy: A six-storey building will cast long shadows over neighbouring gardens and windows, and apartment balconies and windows will look into backyards and habitable rooms.
- Traffic and parking: Where will visitors and extra residents park, and how will cars safely exit the building using the narrow local streets?
- The "donut effect": The Victorian Government imposed an 800-metre residential catchment around activity cores, bypassing Council's boundaries. Allowing multi-storey apartments in quiet residential streets reduces developer uptake within the commercial core — and the opportunity to deliver well-located apartments with vibrant shopping and community spaces may be lost.
There is no social licence for inappropriate development.
How to object